The Magpie Bakery Fresh pies, pastries & custom cakes — a storybook bakery in Bloomingdale, NJ
The Bakery & Café
Good coffee. Colorful cold drinks.
The Magpie is also Bloomingdale's neighborhood café, serving coffee alongside iced teas, matcha, and the croissants, donuts, cinnamon rolls, and savory hand pies coming out of the bakery each morning.
Baked Fresh Daily
Fan favorites
What the Magpie is known for — order ahead online and it's boxed and waiting for you.
Cakes & Events
Made for your occasion
From single-tier birthday cakes to full wedding dessert tables and logo-printed corporate cookies — tell us the occasion and we'll bake for it.
Celebration Cakes
Birthdays, showers, tiered designs, and cupcakes — decorated with Melanie to match your party.
Custom cakes →
Wedding Dessert Tables
Cannolis, napoleons, lemon bars, and bread pudding, styled into a spread guests remember.
Wedding desserts →
Corporate Gifts
Custom logo-printed cookies and gift boxes that make your company the favorite client.
Corporate gifts →
Catering Trays
Pastry trays, cookie platters, and dessert spreads scaled to your headcount.
Catering →Google Reviews
What neighbors say
Rated 4.9★ across 317 Google reviews — these are the things neighbors keep coming back to. Read them in their own words on Google.
Celebration cakes designed with Melanie herself — baby-shower sheet cakes, birthdays, and reveal cakes that come out exactly as imagined.
Custom cakes · A theme all through the reviews
Wedding dessert spreads that guests actually finish — cannolis, napoleons, lemon bars, and bread pudding styled for the big day.
Wedding desserts · What couples mention
Vegan and allergen-friendly bakes that nobody can tell apart from the classics — a birthday-cake story reviewers keep retelling.
Vegan treats · From the vegan crowd
Morning regulars swear by the case: donuts, croissants, and hand pies that sell out before the afternoon.
Donuts & pastries · The daily-pastry faithful
Meet the Baker
Melanie Stripeikis
Melanie has spent 30+ years baking, and it shows in every hand-rolled crust that leaves her oven. She opened The Magpie Bakery to give Bloomingdale the kind of neighborhood bakery where the person decorating your cake is the one who asks about your party. Come in once and she'll probably remember your order the next time.
Visit Us
Find the Magpie
The Magpie Bakery · 2-14 Riverside Square, Bloomingdale, NJ 07403 · (973) 291-6756
Tue–Sat 8–5 · Sun 8–3- Mon8:00 AM – 3:00 PM
- Tue – Sat8:00 AM – 5:00 PM
- Sun8:00 AM – 3:00 PM
Off she goes — back to the ovens. See you at Riverside Square.
Warm from the oven, ready when you are
Order online for pickup or delivery from The Magpie Bakery in Bloomingdale — or just follow the smell of butter.